Mayors commit to pluralism and American democracy

By
Learn more about Chris Walsh.
Chris Walsh
Director, Global Policy
George W. Bush Institute

What’s happening?

This week, the United States Conference of Mayors released the Oklahoma City Declaration. It clearly states that America’s bold democratic freedoms are both the best antidote to political violence as well as the powerful catalyst for prosperity at home and around the world. Two hundred and thirty mayors from 41 states and Puerto Rico pledged to embrace pluralism, compromise, and persuasion, while condemning political violence, in support of building a better America.

“Mayors live the American experiment like no one else. Running a city demands constant action and results. And so, every day, mayors guide our residents through these democratic processes, respecting pluralism, seeking compromise, and using the art of persuasion,” the declaration states. “We understand that political violence not only destroys lives, it threatens the greatest experiment in human history.”

Why it matters?

This group of nearly 250 mayors showcases how America’s political and geographic diversity is committed to the bedrock values of the United States. “As mayors, we lead our residents toward a common purpose…We are principled and pragmatic. We get things done,” they say. “We work together despite being registered with different political parties, or with no political party at all. We embrace our shared experience as mayors, as humans, and as Americans.”

Despite what partisan pundits may say, people of different beliefs living in different places across this nation love their country, its freedoms, and the American way of life. We passionately argue over differences because democratic citizens do battle with words, ideas, ballot boxes, institutions, and the rule of law, not violence or tyranny. It’s invigorating to see many political leaders from across the ideological spectrum affirm these principles.

Importantly, the University of Chicago’s research has shown that the American public is hungry for joint condemnations of political violence, like the mayors’ statement, by Democrats and Republicans.

And it’s encouraging that the Oklahoma Declaration adds to the seemingly growing ranks of state and local leaders who exhibit courageous pluralism – unapologetically defending the freedoms and character of their political opponents.

Bottom line

It’s easy to despair over headlines about toxic polarization and looming political violence in the United States; or to believe that our political leaders have abandoned civility. But the Oklahoma City Declaration reminds us that our country is bound by a set of shared values and a commitment to the American experiment. It also exemplifies that the spirit and practice of pluralism – when people, of varying beliefs and backgrounds, respect each other as equal citizens in a democracy – are alive and well in the United States. If you’re tempted to disengage from civic life because it’s become too toxic, be assured there are many in this country who are committed to a better, more patriotic way. Responsible citizens should seek ways to incentivize more of this behavior from their leaders.