Chapter 2:
Stabilizing societies and saving millions of lives
Imagine what could have been if America and our allies had decided not to act 23 years ago when we launched the President’s Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief (PEPFAR),
What if the United States had decided that a disease devastating another continent was tragic, but ultimately just not America’s responsibility?
While we can’t know precisely what the world would look like, we do know the facts:
- 26 million lives were saved.
- Nearly 8 million babies were born HIV-free.
- Countries were able to build futures for their citizens despite the devastating toll the disease took on so many.
But the stark, plain fact remains: Because of PEPFAR – and the dedication of governments and the private sector, and organizations like the Global Fund to Fight AIDS, Tuberculosis, and Malaria; UNAIDS; and the World Health Organization – the world is a more stable, stronger, and more prosperous place than it would have been.
The United States, through PEPFAR, directed taxpayer support to nations with the greatest HIV/AIDS burden, and thus, ensured the greatest impact. Most of PEPFAR’s bilateral funding has supported countries in sub-Saharan Africa.
The data throughout this piece illustrates PEPFAR’s influence around the world, particularly on the populations most harmed by HIV/AIDS.
1
WHAT IF PEPFAR DIDN’T INNOVATE?
In a revolutionary move, PEPFAR targeted, implemented, and expanded access to lifesaving HIV treatment and prevention, including antiretroviral therapies (ARTs) beginning in 2003 to the areas and regions with the greatest HIV burden. In 2002, before PEPFAR, only about 50,000 of the 4.1 million people in sub-Saharan Africa who needed antiretroviral drugs were receiving them.
As Figure 1 shows, while more than 2 million AIDS-related deaths occurred in 2003 alone, that number had declined to 570,000 by 2025. Without American leadership through the creation of PEPFAR, millions of people would never have gained access to treatment – and the consequences would have snowballed over time as the disease spread.
Effective treatment does more than just suppress HIV – it dramatically reduces transmission, protecting others from the disease. In 2003, there were approximately 2.7 million new HIV infections globally. By 2025, that number was more than halved.
Figure 2: Between 2003 and 2025, new HIV infections declined by 1.5 million

In sub-Saharan Africa, the region with the greatest HIV burden, new infections have fallen 59% between 2010 and 2025. By increasing access to treatment, testing, and prevention resources, PEPFAR partnerships have broken the curve, dramatically reduced new HIV infections across the region, and saved lives.
Figure 3: In Africa, the number of new HIV infections declined to 610,000 by 2025

But PEPFAR has saved more than individual lives; it has saved generations.
Figure 4 shows that at the launch of the program in 2003, an estimated 360,000 children had died from AIDS. That number was increasing, and historical analysis indicates that, without PEPFAR, there would have been an additional 2.8 million new child HIV infections from 2000 to 2022.
Instead, PEPFAR provided interventions, including programs designed to prevent mother-to-child transmission and ARTs for children and pregnant and breastfeeding women. These integrated components turned the tide and, by 2024, PEPFAR helped ensure that nearly 8 million babies were born HIV-free, stopping this disease from reaching, and devastating, a new generation.
2
WHAT IF PEPFAR DIDN’T PROTECT FAMILIES?
Reflecting on the time before PEPFAR, former Global AIDS Coordinator Dr. Mark Dybul said this in an oral history of the program captured in 2023: “Most diseases kill the very old and the very young. But this disease was killing the most productive and reproductive parts of society. So not only were many households run by orphans, but entire villages were run by orphans, because everyone [else] was dead.”
The devastating loss of the most productive individuals in society was estimated to have an impact far beyond their lifetime. In the 1990s, a study in Tanzania found that losing an adult to AIDS would remove impacted children from school as they had to take on greater responsibility at home. School attendance of young people ages 15 to 20 was reduced by half if the household had lost an adult female family member within the year.
For children born into an HIV pandemic, the likelihood of living without a parent or guardian was high. In his 2000 address to the United Nations, then-Secretary General Kofi Annan noted that 11 million children had been orphaned by the pandemic. This significant rise in orphaned and vulnerable children would have exacerbated political and societal instability across an already fragile landscape.

Recognizing this threat, U.S. congressional leadership worked with the George W. Bush administration to require that 10% of PEPFAR funding annually be set aside for orphans and vulnerable children. These targeted interventions supported the children left behind, while treatment and prevention programming kept other children’s parents alive. Across Africa, the number of children orphaned by the death of one or both parents from AIDS declined from 11.6 million in 2003 to 9.8 million in 2025 as illustrated in Figure 5.
3
WHAT IF PEPFAR DIDN’T SUPPORT ECONOMIC GROWTH?
Investments in health have a direct impact on economic productivity and growth. A World Bank report in 1993 estimated that the AIDS epidemic could cause a slowing of per-capita income by 0.6 percentage point each year in the 10 hardest-hit sub-Saharan African countries.
HIV/AIDS poses devastating economic costs. The disease disproportionately impacts adults in the most economically productive years of their lives, a 2003 World Bank working paper argued. In 1990, 11% of 20-year-old men and 4% of 20-year-old women in South Africa were not expected to survive their 40th birthday. But against the estimated trajectory of HIV/AIDS rates, the study modelled that these premature deaths were projected to jump to 36% and 54%, respectively. By the time the study was published, South Africa had more people living with HIV than any other country.

On the continent of Africa particularly, AIDS’ impact on food security was overwhelming. In 2002, a report by the U.N. Food and Agriculture Organization estimated that the disease had already killed more than 7 million agricultural workers in 17 years across the 25 most-affected African countries. The organization anticipated that by 2020, up to 26% of the labor force would be lost to the disease, devastating the region’s agricultural sector.
Every premature death or individual unable to work due to debilitating illness translated not only into vanished wages for their family but also into lost economic drivers for their community. Countries lost workers, teachers and farmers; communities lost entrepreneurs and small businesses; governments gained dramatic burdens on already fragile health systems and lost tax revenue from a suffering population.
Festus Mogae, former president of Botswana (1998-2008), framed the dire situation when in 2000, he said, “We really are in a national crisis. We are threatened with extinction. People are dying in chillingly high numbers. We are losing the best of young people. It is a crisis of the first magnitude.”
The Bush Institute’s series, PEPFAR Beyond 2030, illustrates the profound impact that PEPFAR support had on life expectancy. Figure 6 shows that countries with longstanding partnerships with PEPFAR experienced an increase in average life expectancy of as much as 18 years.
PEPFAR made ARTs more accessible to people living with HIV, turning a death sentence into a path for a productive life. As people lived longer, they were able to start businesses and invest in their communities. PEPFAR’s intervention – and the productive lives saved – coincided with an increase in per-capita GDP across sub-Saharan Africa. Figure 7 illustrates this significant gain – from $600 in 2000 to more than $1,600 in 2025.
Africa especially has become home to some of the fastest-growing economies in the world. Without PEPFAR’s lead in the expansion of treatment, countries already vulnerable and grappling with poverty and weak economic development would have been set back by decades in seeking to provide economic stability for their citizens.
4
WHAT IF PEPFAR DIDN'T ACCELERATE REGIONAL STABILITY?
At the height of the pandemic, HIV/AIDS was the perfect storm to strike vulnerable states. Across countries with already fragile institutions, health systems became overwhelmed, workforces were being decimated, and millions of children were growing up without parents. Fear and misinformation spread among populations, inciting public panic, vigilantism, and distrust of not only medical systems but also governments.

Then-Secretary General Kofi Annan addressed this directly, saying in his 2000 remarks, “The breakdown of health and education services, the obstruction of humanitarian assistance, the displacement of whole populations and a high infection rate among soldiers – as in other groups which move back and forth across the continent – all these ensure that the epidemic spreads ever further and faster.”
The United States recognized this. In 2000, both the U.S. National Intelligence Estimate and the United Nations Security Council (via Resolution 1308) specifically noted that the unchecked spread of HIV was catalyzing political instability, increasing governments’ fragility, and accelerating institutional collapse across sub-Saharan Africa.
As a specific example, Uganda in the 1990s and early 2000s experienced a drastic increase in children orphaned by AIDS. These vulnerable children, left without options, became easy targets for recruitment to the Lord’s Resistance Army, an extremist armed group that actively waged a guerrilla campaign to overthrow the government.
According to researchers published in the Journal of Development Economics, the successful expansion of ARTs, primarily through PEPFAR, reduced social conflict outbreaks related to organized and spontaneous events, elections, economic grievances, or human rights. Using the Social Conflict Analysis Database, Figure 8 illustrates the relationship between social conflict and the expansion of ART. The map on the left shows that countries in Africa with an HIV prevalence rate above the median in 2001 experienced more social conflict events than those with a low prevalence rate. The map on the right shows that after 2001, when access to ART was expanded through programs like PEPFAR, the incidence of social conflict was relatively the same across countries.
Figure 8: Social conflict decreased amid better access to ART through programs like PEPFAR.

5
CONCLUSION
Because of PEPFAR, the vast majority of a generation was saved from not only HIV/AIDS but also from the follow-on effects of the pandemic and its profound societal repercussions.
PEPFAR provided a clear, data-driven, partner-led framework to help countries reduce the looming catastrophe of the combined mortality, economic, and institutional pressure that threatened stability. It supported and repaired the foundations on which healthy, resilient government and private-sector systems could thrive.
See next: Chapter 3 and the conclusion of this series: Imagining a world without PEPFAR, as the Bush Institute marks World AIDS Day on Dec. 1.
The Bush Institute would like to thank Alec Clark, Southern Methodist University Tower Scholar (Class of 2027) for his assistance in completing this project.